This clip is just under an hour long. This happened in the US.
Any links to textual articles discussing the case or the background to it?
No, I found it myself on YouTube. A couple of average guys wrote the opensource software to make bitcoin transactions completely private and secure from any snooping or identity discovering. Even the FBI couldn’t find or track the transactions. So the FBI ruins their lives. The constitution doesn’t help you when they want to take you down. These guys weren’t even making money, just letting others use their software for free.
When you are Microsoft, anyone can use your spreadsheet program to commit crimes, and Microsoft knows that some people are doing just that. But no one convicts Microsoft of conspiracy. When you are the little guy who writes software to give users privacy, a completely standard applies. A large amount of exculpatory evidence never made it before the jury.
This is why I like to use a Librem 5. The Librem 5 doesn’t actually protect our freedoms from the government and we know because otherwise everyone at Purism would go to jail for unjust reasons, but it also doesn’t work so it makes a statement that something is wrong in society.
If it came out tomorrow that the Librem 5 was running Android with 12 GB of ram and the reason it’s so slow is that everything we think it does on 3 GB of RAM is happening in an emulator, I’d still like it because it lets us live in denial about how bad things really are.
How did they make any money from this, if they did make any money?
An article linked above talks about “forfeiting $237 million”. Whose money was that? That’s quite a lot of money. Pretty good for an open source project.
Other link for background reading: Samourai Wallet - Wikipedia
Don’t go there.
With more people using online software like Office 365, before you know it Microsoft will be under pressure from the government to perform 24/7 surveillance on all the Office documents stored / accessed / used in their online service because otherwise Microsoft will be criminally liable for their role in it when a document is used to commit a crime.
However that kind of logic could eventually even extend to non-online software (like traditional Microsoft Office). Because “pedorists” don’t you know.
Not that I would ever use either.
If you watch the original video at the top of this chain, you’ll see this guy who wrote the software explaining how all he did was to write and distribute the software as opensource. He did not have access to anyone else’s money and did not charge anyone for anything. The $237 million was what the state would have charged them for restitution if they didn’t accept the plea deal. But in addition, he would have sat in prison for 30 years if he didn’t accept the plea deal. The state lacked the evidence and basis for charging him with money laundering and other actual crimes. He was only charged with “conspiracy to commit" the crimes. The burden of proof is lower that way. The assumption that the state used to prove the crimes was that there would be no need for such privacy if not to commit other crimes. That was enough to prove guilt. It’s all in the video.
The government blamed this guy and a partner because his bitcoin anonymity software made it possible for real bad guys to get away with real financial crimes and not get caught. So the government totaled-up the losses from those other crimes and it came to $237 million. They can’t catch the crooks. So they go after the guys who made it possible for the bad guys to commit those other crimes. But still, when was the last time that a Ford or Chevy executive went to prison because someone used a Ford or Chevy car for their get away car in a bank robbery? I can’t see the difference.