Transfer files between the L5 and networked computers

[kieran]

If your router supports FTP for sharing storage that is attached to your router then it probably supports SMB (Samba / Windows file sharing) too. That would be a second option to explore.

Security comment: Having storage attached to your router is somewhat exposing yourself. It gives you fewer options to put barriers between your storage and the internet … assuming that the intention is not to share your storage with the internet.

I can’t speak for Nemo but nautilus out-of-the-box seems to offer: ftp, nfs, smb, sftp, dav. That’s on a desktop / laptop. I can only guess whether those options would exist on your phone if and when nautilus is available or whether Nemo offers those same options.

One fun option, discussed previously I think, is to enable the SSH server on the phone … and then you can use sshfs on a desktop/laptop to access files directly on the phone. You could, alternatively, use an SFTP client (like FileZilla) on the desktop/laptop if you prefer. That is a different approach though because you are pushing/pulling on the desktop/laptop. (So that is the reverse of using sftp in Nemo, if Nemo supports that.)

Honestly, Linux probably offers too many options - and yet everyone’s environment is different.

@amarok

thumb drive

The µSD card is an alternative if you intend to use sneakernet.

[dos]

@amarok

If I recall, file transfer from the L5 to a thumb drive is not yet implemented - @Purism, correct me if I’m wrong

You’re wrong There was no automount, but it should be there now with latest updates (and you could always mount it manually of course). USB thumb drive then works exactly the same as microSD card (which in fact is also seen in the system as a USB mass storage device).

@kieran

One fun option, discussed previously I think, is to enable the SSH server on the phone … and then you can use sshfs on a desktop/laptop to access files directly on the phone.

Yeah, scp is a natural way to transfer a file to/from the phone for me, it comes to me without even thinking

[kieran]

For completeness then, if you enable the SSH server on the phone, and command line is acceptable / desirable, you can also use the sftp command.

---

Another option, not sure of its current "working" status, is to plug the phone in to the desktop/laptop via USB and it may present its storage as a USB mass storage device to the desktop/laptop. Even if it only did that for the µSD card, that could still be used to exchange files, albeit more with a focus on bulk movement since it is inherently less convenient than using the network.

[kieran]

PS I hesitate to “write up” any of this because I like to test what I have written and I have no way of testing. Soon though …

[dos]

@kieran

Another option, not sure of its current “working” status, is to plug the phone in to the desktop/laptop via USB and it may present its storage as a USB mass storage device to the desktop/laptop.

No out-of-box support for that right now. A sufficiently motivated user can set it up and export µSD card as a mass storage device by configuring USB gadgets (I’ve done that and it works ;)), or even set MTP responder up to export anything on a filesystem level (haven’t tried it personally yet, but I know that Mobian got it integrated so it should be possible to replicate their setup).

[dos]

@dos

(I’ve done that and it works ;))

Even found it:

#!/bin/sh
set -x
rmmod g_multi
rmmod g_ether
cd /sys/kernel/config/
cd usb_gadget
mkdir g1
cd g1
echo "0x316d" > idVendor
echo "0x4c05" > idProduct
echo "0xEF" > bDeviceClass
echo "0x02" > bDeviceSubClass
echo "0x01" > bDeviceProtocol
mkdir strings/0x409
echo "0123456789" > strings/0x409/serialnumber
echo "Purism, SPC" > strings/0x409/manufacturer
echo "Librem 5" > strings/0x409/product
mkdir functions/ecm.usb0
mkdir functions/acm.GS0
mkdir functions/mass_storage.0
mkdir configs/c.1
mkdir configs/c.1/strings/0x409
echo "CDC ACM+ECM" > configs/c.1/strings/0x409/configuration
echo "/dev/sda" > functions/mass_storage.0/lun.0/file
echo "Librem 5" > functions/mass_storage.0/lun.0/inquiry_string
ln -s functions/acm.GS0 configs/c.1
ln -s functions/ecm.usb0 configs/c.1
ln -s functions/mass_storage.0 configs/c.1
echo "38100000.usb" > UDC

This sets up a USB gadget with three functions - serial, ethernet and mass storage (with /dev/sda being exported). Make sure to unmount any SD partition before doing that though - it is a block level export (as opposed to other tech like MTP that exports things on a filesystem level), so it will be your PC that will mount these partitions on its own!

Related ticket: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/linux-next/-/issues/182

[kieran]

Oh, yeah, MTP too.

As I said, almost too many options.

Over time, if looking to gain mainstream customers, I think MTP (or something functionally equivalent) is needed. Users of other phones have come to expect plugging in via USB as an option, and for it to work seamlessly out-of-the-box. USB has the advantage of better physical security (but watch out for “bad chargers”).

As you imply, MTP is safer than USB mass storage class because while some users will know to umount first if using mass storage class, many will not.

[uzanto]

For my desktop to laptop I use Syncthing

[fralb5]

For me it’s rsync which comes without thinking , which means I need ssh server running in the background

What would be awesome is to have an option to activate/deactivate SSH in the settings (if installed) !
Else, I will probably have 2 shortcuts, one to disable sshd, one to activate sshd (as I have on my actual pc)

[dos]

@fralb5

What would be awesome is to have an option to activate/deactivate SSH in the settings (if installed) !

Would be? It’s already there for ages

[kieran]

@fralb5

What would be awesome is to have an option to activate/deactivate SSH in the settings (if installed) !

So awesome that it already exists?: [MyL5] Received my Librem 5 (Evergreen)

Argh, beat me by 1 minute, @dos

[ruff]

It doesn’t work for tinysshd though
Edit: but yes it’s about sharing and tiny doesn’t give any other service but shell.

[fralb5]

@dos @kieran : Hey ! I missed that ! THAT’S AWESOME !

[spacemanspiffy]

I’m planning on setting something up where whenever my home Wifi connects, mount my home server’s storage drive via NFS.
When Wifi disconnects, unmount.

I can browse the same drive via SMB on my Android but having this setup I think will be pretty slick.

Still need a good adaptive GUI file manager option though, but that is coming.

Edit: And only a few minutes later I happen across this: https://source.puri.sm/adrien.plazas/nautilus/-/commit/0732ac4a1dd3177c04384f1c55e05ed7fbf76e91

[david.boddie]

Provide method for copying files between devices (#71) · Issues · Librem5 /...

[amarok]

@dos

There was no automount, but it should be there now

Yes! Thanks. I just checked and my USB-C to USB-A/micro-B drive now mounts automatically when inserted.

[amarok]

@kieran

Having storage attached to your router is somewhat exposing yourself

True story! A few years ago, Asus routers that had built-in USB/FTP/Samba were compromised because there was no password protection included. They’ve corrected that now. Still maybe not the best option, as you and others have pointed out.

[joao.azevedo]

@spacemanspiffy

Edit: And only a few minutes later I happen across this: https://source.puri.sm/adrien.plazas/nautilus/-/commit/0732ac4a1dd3177c04384f1c55e05ed7fbf76e91

don’t ruin the surprise

[amarok]

I like the scp command.

Here’s a tutorial for those who don’t yet know how to use it:
https://linuxize(dot)com/post/how-to-use-scp-command-to-securely-transfer-files/

Edit: Reminder to set up ssh first.

[Brad]

I had just assumed that connection to a network would work similar to say desktop Ubuntu, but In reality I don’t have any experience with Pure OS.

Can anybody tell me if samba share is supported in Pure OS (and by extension I assumed the L5)?