So, just a random thought, given the libre community nature of free software, if the guys at support are too busy what if the guys here on the forums try to help you? Is the problem literally that the Librem 5 modem isn’t working? I have a Librem 5 where the modem is working. Maybe that can be useful in some way.
1 Like
OK I guess I wasn’t too terribly clear…no I am not expecting anything this weekend.
I first contacted them (this time around) because I wanted help reflashing the modem firmware (an operation you have to contact support for because it’s risky). I got that help very, very quickly, but then reported the phone still couldn’t make calls. Support wanted a screen shot of the utility screen, which I sent them two days later. This time there was no quick response, not even an acknoledgement that it was received.
This is exactly the point at which they dropped me last time (i.e., right after I sent them data they had asked for), so admittedly my antennae are up, waiting for it to happen again. Realistically, I won’t conclude it has happened again for a while (a week or so, and after follow up emails); at this point I’m just worried.
2 Likes
Personally, I think it’s a bad modem. Or, given that this modem is already a replacement, perhaps the antenna is defective. I just have to walk through this (again) with tech support and either find out that’s what it is, or something else. For now we’re just trying to establish I have the right firmware. Once we’re there I’ll describe what I am seeing in great detail (weak signals even right next to a cell tower, the phone having a hard time finding t-mobile, etc.). We’ll just have to see…and it depends on staying in contact with support.
1 Like
I have two Librem 5’s, and one has a bad modem because I opened it up for the fun of seeing the inside. And, inside when I tried to detach and reattach everything I learned the hard way that the modem connection is fairly weak and should be handled with care, by visibly breaking it after applying too much force.
For me, inside the mobile settings there is a menu that has fine control of whether we are using 3G, or 4G or whatever. Have you messed with that?
As far as I can see, there is no default. This was kind of new to me versus Android, which seemed to always just handle this stuff magically.
1 Like
Purism is a small company, and I think support consists of 2-4 people max. With the amount of people they are having to assist, and the VAST area of support that Linux requires, especially for people unfamiliar with Linux, there is just A LOT of demand and so little time. On top of this most of the things being requested are probably things that have been answered already many times.
That being said I think that there are cultural things that might be at play here as well. I do not think that any of the support staff is from North America. This means that things like convenience and the customer is always right are most likely not part of the dynamic. This can be jarring for us Americans.
All this said, I feel like I have nothing but good support from Purism and their support staff. I am just realistic about the turn around time due to their size and work!
3 Likes
… which also means that reproducing a problem that only happens in the US (for example) in one specific location - or getting to a conclusion that there is a problem with the specific modem - could take time.
It would be the same challenge in my country, but worse. No staff of any type located here - so no possibility of any staff directly reproducing the problem. No familiarity with the three networks that are available here - and the possible quirks of those networks.
I think there is work needed to at least give more logging information about what is happening on the host side when the modem is not able to be persuaded to do its thing.
After an appropriate amount of time, and assuming still no response, you can also try pinging @JCS to see whether he can follow up on your behalf.
As an aside, last time I tried to use that, which was recently, - I wanted 4G-only now that the 3G network is defunct, and the 2G network was shut down a decade ago - it actually gave an error. I don’t know whether that’s because it (indirectly) depends on what is negotiated with the carrier or because something else went wrong. (So I left it at “2G, 3G, 4G (Preferred)”, which does work for me anyway.)
1 Like
That was the last thing that happened before the ghosting of 2022: I was told to switch to 2G, 3G, 4G (Preferred) and attempt to make a call, then send the log.
So I made sure that’s what’s selected this time. No need to waste a round of log-sending.
1 Like
I think though when you send in your phone for repair, i.e. you don’t have it, that should be some sort of priority and for the time it takes, a simple status update on what’s going on with it, even to say we haven’t gotten to it, reassures me that I’m going to get it back, at this point I’m quite sure that there is a possibility that I won’t get it back. It went in to them before Christmas. Don’t think that is really acceptable no matter where you come from. If the issue is bad enough for someone to send it in (at my expense which was almost $70 CAD with $1000 insurance, now twice) I would think this would be some sort of priority.
The worrisome thing is that I think they do think it’s a priority but they do not have an answer and therefore they haven’t been able to update me or turn it around in a timely fashion. I am sort of torn as to whether I just let them hang on to it or have them send it back so I can at least feel like I can get some use out of it, but I also don’t want to drop another $70 to send it back again.
I’ve defended them from the beginning, but I think it’s not much to ask that they provide regular unprompted updates on my RMA status.
5 Likes
Support provided me your ticket number, and it looks like there have been issues with the shipping carrier. It was reported delivered a month ago. I sent you a private message with details.
6 Likes
You misunderstood, we don’t know where my phone ended up, it looks like it never made it there.
2 Likes
Ohhh, so like, you’re one of the folks who actually needs to be using a Librem 5, because someone is after you.
Come to think of it, that suddenly makes me realize why there are so many forum complaints contrary to my own experience. I’m nobody, they’d let me have as many working Librem 5’s as I want because I’m a naive dingleberry with no state actor after me for anything. They probably hacked me and realized I was just using my devices to play video games anyway.
I wonder how many folks who had issues with Librem 5 were actually dealing with intervention from a third party…
1 Like
Speaking of third parties intervention
I can report that international shipping is on hold because of problems with DHL (since begin December).
I’m waiting for my new L5 and my repaired L5 since then.
All I can do is waiting patiently until this shipping matter is resolved and I’m sure it will.
1 Like
Within the US, I was able to use a Librem 5 as my boarding pass for flights a few months ago. Maybe somebody could buy a bunch of Librem 5s and then go on vacation to Europe? Is there some reason that doesn’t work?
I guess I’ve never been to Europe so I’m ignorant of what the customs paperwork would require for such a case.
1 Like
I don’t think it is that easy.
The problem seems to be the (removable) battery.
The only company who is willing and able to ship the L5’s (or other electronics with a battery) is DHL.
According to support they tried to use other firms, but those refuse the shipment.
There are strickt regulations transporting batteries on a plane and I’m sure you would not be able to board the plane with let’s say 10 L5’s in your bagage.
I wonder if shipping by boat is less strickt.
1 Like
That’s why I ordered and extra battery when I got mine phone because I don’t think you can just order a battery on it’s own, not sure exactly.
2 Likes
You miss the fact that we are talking about the current problem that Purism has an issue with DHL and thus can no longer send electronics that CONTAIN a battery outside the continent.
This has nothing to do with ordering extra batteries.
1 Like
Yes, I reported my L5 was unable to make 4g calls in Oct 22.
I was contacted by João Azevedo who was initially very helpful. He got me to update things and requested I send a log file (which I did). He replied on 24th Oct saying they had found an error and were looking into it. I emailed a few weeks later (politely) requesting an update but he just refused to reply.
I emailed ‘support’ on 29th December asking how I could escalate the issue within Purism. I received a reply from João Fonseca asking me to try a couple of things (confirming what I had already sent), which I responded to on Jan 4th. I received no reply to that email or a further one a month later asking for an update.
So, they are just blanking me now and I am left to conclude that my L5 (UK version) is not capable of 4g calling and they (Purism) just does not want to state that in writing.
So having waited 4 years on my phone, I find that it is about to become obsolete after just over 1 year of limited use and Purism won’t even respond to my emails to update me on the issue.
I see now why they are showing something like 83% 1-star reviews on Trustpilot.
I am really disappointed with their attitude and will no longer believe any of the ‘hype’ they come up with.
2 Likes
It has now been 2 1/2 calendar weeks since sending log files to tech support for my phone, and I pinged asking for an update on Wednesday.
So far, silence.
(The phone will make a call, but only if I am within a few hundred feet of a tower.)
2 Likes
I have had some correspondence from Joao, but never support directly. I have been communicating with him in the last few weeks about getting a replacement phone which they are doing seeing as it was lost when I sent it in for my RMA. But when I was troubleshooting my modem issues there wasn’t much coming back from support at all, I would just ping Joao once a week to see if there was any progress. I have a feeling they might be stumped and haven’t sorted the issue out. I really think they will probably have to pivot to some other modem, perhaps not a very FOSS unit but if it doesn’t work then what is the point in having it even if it’s as close to a FOSS modem as we’ll get.
2 Likes