Yesterday I received my phone. It’s thick.
I’ve been using android phones for a decade or more now. When I broke my last one, I switched to the pinephone (postmarketOS edition) running mobian; this has been my daily driver for a few months now. My main fear when unboxing the L5 was that might not be significantly better than the PP. Luckily I was wrong. Those are my first impressions (in random order):
It’s thick, and /seems/ to be heavy, when compared to the PP; in reality the weight is not that much (197g vs 261 on my scale).
There was no ‘shipping screen protector’ attached. Is this expected? I read there should be and I should remove it.
It’s way faster than the PP. Boot time is approximately the same (cannot compare because of number of autostart programs I have). Scrolling is smoooth too
Battery life seems better, too. The PP never lasted a night with screen off (in offline mode), while I kept the L5 with all the switches off and it was still alive in the morning.
On the PP, I’ve been experiencing lot of random freezes, and a few phosh crashes. On the L5, I’ve already had some random ‘poweroff’ (splash screen and then the phone is off) and a couple of 'the phone is working (as I can press the volume button and hear the sound) but the screen is black and it won’t turn on. edit: I spoke too early, got a random freeze on L5 too
It’s not fair to compare build quality, given the difference in price: PP is quite solid, I like the smooth back cover; however, when I received it I got almost no phone signal. I realized the antenna was unplugged and had to open it and re plug the antenna. L5 quality is wonderful. Better audio speaker (louder and cleaner), nice/strange warm flash, nice status LED (bigger than the one on the PP), the touch screen is more responsive… they are different beasts (with different prices: I had to pay ~180EUR for the PP and ~662EUR for the L5, so the difference in quality was expected)
I’m having problems with bluetooth. It works well on the PP (except that is not supported for audio calls, but at least I can listen to the music), while on the L5 I cannot even connect to the headphones (nor to other speakers)
Phone signal reception is also better on the L5. Could not test GPS yet
It does not see my external micro sd card (nothing in dmesg nor in df) while on the PP it was working… strange
Overall I’m satisfied, I’ll see if I can fix the bluetooth problem and I’ll try out the GPS soon
I can’t even get the modem to work on my PP. I’ve been trying for a long time. I think there’s something wrong with the hardware (yes I checked the antenna connectors). Since my L5 is still a long way out (I ordered January 2019), I would just order a PP convergence bundle but they’re not selling them right now. Total sadness.
Also, you can make use of the repairability feature and only order a new motherboard (out-of-stock, right now) and a PP docking bar (for convergence). There are videos on how to replace the motherboard. (I guess you didn’t kill switched off the modem…)
(Well, that’s community edition which has ended). I expect the motherboards to be back in stock after the factories start the production again after the recently Chinese New Year vacation. Probably they will be available at the same time with the restocking of PP with the default OS (March-April).
It is a little bit fiddly to ensure that both the SIM card and the uSD card are correctly positioned in the tray, and stay that way as you slide the tray back in. Maybe bring the tray out again and check, if you haven’t already.
If still no joy, I would try a different uSD card, for fault isolation purposes.
Thanks a lot for this comparison to the PinePhone. A friend of mine lended his PinePhone for a few weeks to me and while it’s very fun to mess around with due to it being so open, I use it a lot less than I anticipated because it’s slow and the battery life is really bad (even with everything toggled off, but with wifi only soft-toggled to easily enable it while at home). I hope it becomes a bit faster and gets better battery life with updates. If that happens I might start carrying it beside my android phone daily.
If the Librem 5 already has better battery and is faster at the same time as it also has room for battery and performance improvements, that makes me more optimistic!
Funny. My first impression when I opened the box was that Librem 5 is not at all so thick and heavy. I compared to my Moto G6 and the only difference is that it is a little bit thicker. But reading the terrible noise about how thick and heavy it is I expected much more. I suppose that people are comparing to those extremely thin phones - not to medium size phones like Moto G6. Compared to my old Nokia N900 it is even thinner but has a larger screen. But everyone has his own taste.
I really like the sturdiness of Librem 5. I use my phone in the forest and I would be very nervous with a thin phone. I cannot tell how it compares in other respects yet but it was important to change the settings of the TP-link C7 router to 20 MHz bandwidth to get a stable connection - it was useless with the auto setting. And the date setting was OK once I realized that I had a Swedish SIM card and set the time zone to Stockholm. Because you nowadays can use your SIM cards in the whole EU it is important that you are careful with the settings.
The phone antenna seems fairly good but I have to check the WiFi antenna because I have poor signal even close to the router.
But it is nice to have Debian in the phone (as I have in all computers). Almost everything is familiar except Gnome which I have never used. I suppose it will take some time to learn all the quirks …